Closed Doors and Contraindications: Florence v Benzaquen, 2021 ONCA 523
By: Legate Injury Lawyers
In day-to-day life, a closed door can represent security. We close doors to keep inclement weather out of our homes or to ensure privacy for sensitive conversations. Unfortunately, in the context of law, a closed door can keep the wrong things out and present a barrier to justice.
In a recent decision from the Court of Appeal for Ontario (“ONCA”), Florence v Benzaquen, the majority appeared to close the door to claims by children for negligence that occurred before they were conceived. While I agree that there are persuasive reasons to limit these claims in certain circumstances, a firmly closed door without the opportunity for nuance may run contrary to access to justice.
The Facts about the Florence v Benzaquen Case
In Florence, 25-year-old Dana sought assistance from her doctor after attempting to conceive for only a few weeks. Her doctor prescribed the fertility drug, Serophene. In a quickly moving set of events, Dana was pregnant by the end of the month and gave birth to premature triplets at only 26 weeks’ gestation.
Dana, her husband, and her triplets brought an action against the doctor for: (1) failing to obtain Dana’s informed consent regarding the drug, and (2) prescribing a drug that was contraindicated in the circumstances. They alleged that because the drug carried risks of conceiving multiple fetuses and premature birth, it should not have been offered to Dana because of her young age, the short time of attempted conception, and other clinical indicators. The motions judge dismissed the triplets’ claim pursuant to rule 21 as having no basis in law. The triplets appealed.
What followed was a split court. The judges disagreed on whether the allegation of a drug being contraindicated is nuanced enough to impact the duty of care analysis.
Duty of Care According to the Majority
Writing for the majority, Gillese JA dismissed the appeal. She framed the determinative question on appeal as:
Is it settled law, in Ontario, that a physician does not owe a duty of care to a future child for alleged negligence that occurred pre-conception?
Gillese JA held that the answer is yes. In her opinion, the duty of care analysis remains the same regardless of whether a prescribed drug is contraindicated. She explained that Bovingdon (Litigation Guardian of) v Hergott, Paxton v Ramji, and Liebig v Guelph General Hospital, clearly closed the door to finding that a doctor can owe a duty of care to an unconceived child, especially when prescribing fertility drugs to the mother. Proximity is not established because a doctor does not provide advice to or receive instructions from an unconceived child. Additionally, several policy reasons militate against finding a duty of care. The most prominent is that a doctor would have a conflict of interest between the mother and future child if the mother chooses to risk the potential side effects of a medical treatment.
One troublesome implication of the majority’s reasons is that a doctor will be able to prescribe dangerous drugs to a pregnant mother without needing to consider whether it may cause defects or disabilities to a child who may be conceived and born in the near future. This is a particularly troubling result when considering the fact that current or potential pregnancy is routinely considered when providing medical care. Children would be born without any avenue to claim future care costs that only exist because of the doctor’s negligence.
A Welcome Dissent About the Duty of Care Analysis
Due to a welcome dissent by ACJO Fairburn, children may have the opportunity to reopen the door to these types of claims in the future. He reframed the determinative question as:
Is it settled law, in Ontario, that there are no circumstances in which a physician could owe a duty of care to a future child for alleged negligence that occurred pre-conception? (Emphasis in original.)
ACJO Fairburn held that the answer is no. He explained that based on a critical reading of the case law, the characteristic of a prescribed drug being contraindicated may, indeed, establish a duty of care between the doctor and unconceived child. In Bovingdon and Paxton, Feldman JA expressly contemplated the possibility of finding a duty of care where a drug is contraindicated. Further, Liebig, read in context, did not make a blanket holding that a doctor can never owe a duty of care to an unconceived child.
With respect to the majority’s policy concerns, ACJO Fairburn stated that any concerns regarding a conflict of interest, or the child’s inability to provide instructions to the doctor, fall away if the drug ought not to have been prescribed at all. In this case, the mother would not be in a position to make a decision that is contrary to her unconceived child because she would have no decision to make. Their interests would be aligned. Only time will tell if and how ACJO Fairburn’s dissent in Florence v Benzaquen will pave the way for future claims. I don’t know about you, but I’m keeping my fingers crossed for an appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.