Medical Opinions Not Required to Start Limitation Periods in Motor Vehicle Accident Lawsuits: Sanei v. Debarros, 2024 ONCA 104
Feb 09, 2024 Link
Judges: Hourigan, Roberts and Coroza JJ.A.
Factual Background:
On Feb 2, 2013, the Plaintiff/Appellant was injured in a motor vehicle accident. The action did not commence until March 2, 2016. The Appellant pleaded that he had not discovered “until recently” that his injuries would meet the threshold in the Insurance Act. The Defendant/Respondent brought a summary judgment motion on the basis that the action was statute-barred under the Limitations Act. The summary judgment motion was allowed, and the action was dismissed. The motion judge found that based on the medical evidence and the appellant’s evidence of his injuries being serious and permanent were discoverable well within the two-year limitation period.
Issue:
Did the plaintiff have enough evidence to have discovered that his injuries met the threshold under s. 267.5 of the Insurance Act?
Holding:
Yes
Key Take Aways:
- In Ontario, the limitation period for motor vehicle accident lawsuits begins when the plaintiff knew or ought to have known their injuries met the threshold for a serious and permanent impairment under the Insurance Act.
- An injured person does not need to be certain that their injuries meet the threshold, only that a reasonable person would have thought so.
- Medical opinions are not required to start the limitation period.
- To require a plaintiff to meet the evidentiary burden as set out in s. 4.3 of the Ontario Regulation 461/96 Court Proceedings for Automobile Accidents that Occur on or After November 1, 1996 before commencing their action would have the effect of moving “the needle too close to certainty.”
- The onus is on the plaintiff to prove they do not know about their serious and permanent injury within the limitation period.
Reasoning
The Ontario Court of Appeal stated the following principles of law as it relates to limitation periods and the Insurance Act:
- In an action for injuries arising from a motor vehicle accident, the limitation period will begin to run when: “the claimant knows, or reasonably ought to have known, that their injuries meet the statutory deductible and threshold of serious and permanent impairment under s. 267.5 of the Insurance Act” (para 10).
- The presumption of s. 5(2) of the Limitations Act can be overcome if the injured person can prove that they did not know that they suffered a permanent and serious impairment on the date of the accident. The claimant does not need to prove that they exercised due diligence (para 11).
- If the presumption is rebutted, the limitation period will begin to run on the earlier of the two dates contemplated in s. 5(1)(a) and (b).
- The reasonable person standard under s. 5(1)(b) of the Limitation Act requires consideration of whether the claimant exercised due diligence, requiring the court be satisfied that:
- “a reasonable person in the plaintiff’s circumstances ought to have discovered the claim, and the date of such reasonable discovery must be determined” (para 13).
- If a court determines that the claim was discoverable, they must provide an explanation of why it was discoverable.
- The Court will consider the following evidence in assessing whether the plaintiff has proved their claim for a serious and permanent impairment:
- New medical imaging results or a specific diagnosis.
- Medical records showing that the impairment has worsened over time, or the initial prognosis was that symptoms would improve and have not.
- If the plaintiff has no evidence of a change in their condition, “delayed discovery of a permanent impairment may instead be because they failed to make reasonable inquiries” (para 14).
Analysis
- Was the Motion Judge required to make a specific finding on the date of discoverability?
- The Court of Appeal found that while the motion judge failed to make a specific finding on the date that the Appellant should have discovered his injuries met the threshold, this was not a reversible error. First, the motion judge instructed himself on discoverability under the Insurance Act context. Second, the motion judge’s conclusion was tethered to the timing of the evidence, supporting the finding that the limitation was before March 2, 2014 (para 15-18).
- Was there medical evidence to allow the Appellant to discover his claim before March 2, 2014?
- The Appellant argued that there was no evidence to lead to the discovery that he had suffered a serious and permanent impairment. The Court of Appeal disagreed. On December 19, 2013, a psychiatrist opined that the appellant suffered from a serious psychological disorder. Roberts JA, writing for the Court, noted that the appellant's statement of claim particularized the injuries stated in the December 19, 2013 report, and the appellant’s condition had not changed since the accident, as evidenced by the appellant's examination for discovery (para 19-21).
- Are medical opinions required in the form under s. 4.3 of the Ontario Regulation 461/96 Court Proceedings for Automobile Accidents that Occur on or After November 1, 1996 (“O. Reg. 461/96”) to start a limitation running?
- Section 4.3 explains what evidence a plaintiff must adduce to “prove a permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental or psychological function for the purposes of s. 267.5 of the Insurance Act, including:
- the evidence of one or more physicians (s. 4.3(2) to (4)), and
- corroborative evidence of the change in function alleged to be a permanent serious impairment, which may come from the plaintiff (s. 4.3(5)) (para 22).
- Section 4.3 explains what evidence a plaintiff must adduce to “prove a permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental or psychological function for the purposes of s. 267.5 of the Insurance Act, including:
The Court of Appeal said requiring a plaintiff to have evidence from a physician to start a limitation would “move the needle too close to certainty,” exceeding the required standard to trigger discoverability. The intent and policy underlying the Limitations Act is not to require individuals to commence an action before they know if they have a “substantial chance to succeed in recovering a judgment for damages” (para 23-25).
If you need support, contact Legate Injury Lawyers